Submit a Story!

Counterpoint: Pete Rose Should Not Be Enshrined in the Hall

 
Let's clarify something right off the bat. The Hall of Fame is not ignoring Pete Rose. In fact, Pete Rose is already in the Hall of Fame. Yes, I wrote that correctly. Pete Rose is already in the Hall of Fame. His accomplishments are recognized, and memorabilia from his career is displayed. Depending on when you go, you might also actually see a picture of him (probably sliding head first). What he does not have is a plaque among the Hall of Famers. And this is the way it should be. “Any player, umpire, or club or league official or employee, who shall bet any sum whatsoever upon any baseball game in connection with which the bettor has a duty to perform shall be declared permanently ineligible.” That is the rule that Rose violated. It is displayed in every single clubhouse at every single level of organized, affiliated baseball. And I don't mean displayed like the calorie chart of Whoppers at Burger King. It is displayed on signs large enough to see across the locker ... (link)

Tags:

Related Content
Hal Bodley on XM--on the outside looking in at BBWAA voting
xmmlbchat.blogspot.com 1/14/2009 — Hal Bodley from MLB.com with Charley Steiner says he can't vote for post season BBWAA awards since he's no longer with a newspaper. Notes many newspapers are laying off writers if not going bankrupt, and it's time for the BBWAA to recognize more ...
2009 Hall of Fame Vote: Us vs. Them
seamheads.com 1/14/2009 — More than a week ago, Mike Lynch asked members of my Seamheads group on Facebook, subscribers to SABR’s mailing list (SABR-L), and Seamheads.com writers and readers to cast a Hall of Fame ballot, and 253 of you responded. Here are the final results of the 2009 Seamheads.com Hall of Fame voting...
The Case for Don Mattingly
pinstripealley.com 1/14/2009 — Hall of Fame voting is ridiculous. Why is Jim Rice good enough to be elected now, but not in 1994 (when he was first eligible)? He was the same player. He hasn't hit any more homers or won any more games. (I know the 'reason' is two-fold: it's his ...
Jim Rice, Rickey Henderson fondly recall Madonna
weblogs.newsday.com 1/14/2009 — Newly elected Hall of Famers Rickey Henderson (odd numbers) and Jim Rice (even) join forces Tuesday night to present Letterman's "Late Show" Top 10. A sneak preview from your friends at WatchDog: Top 10 "Highlights of My Hall of Fame Baseball ...
Ignorance is not a sportswriting skill
salon.com 1/14/2009 — I am sick of ignorance being touted as a virtue in my profession. The Web site Seamheads interviewed former longtime newspaper and Sporting News columnist Dave Kindred over the weekend about his baseball Hall of Fame ballot. Results of the voting ...
Put Pete Rose in the Hall of FameBleacher Report - MLB 1/13/2009
Even Jim Rice is in the Hall of Fame now, but Pete Rose isn't. I say put Pete in the Hall. Here's why. You're all quick to throw your heroes away, and you shouldn't. There were tons of McGwire and Sosa jerseys around in the mid '90s. ...
Hall of a momentRed Sox & MLB - BostonHerald.com 1/14/2009
Being elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame is no doubt nice for Jim Rice and Ricky Henderson, but the real thrill must have come last night when they got to present the Top...
Reds fishing plentiful pool for late popMajor League Baseball News 1/14/2009
It could very well be the final opening that gets filled during the offseason, yet a veteran pinch-hitter with some pop becomes an extremely vital addition when the Reds find themselves down one run in the bottom of the ninth this season.
A Hall of Fame cheer for Tommy JohnUSATODAY.com MLB - Top Stories 1/14/2009
Pardon the grumbling, but it must be done. Tommy John didn't make the Hall of Fame again. Missed by a mile in his last year on the ballot. Anyone who didn't vote for him should have to write ulnar collateral ligament construction on the blackboard 100 ...
Henderson Looks Back on His (Disappointing) Days as a YankeeBleacher Report - MLB 1/14/2009
From Bill Madden : Proud and joyful as he was about playing for 25 years and establishing career records for runs scored and stolen bases, Rickey Henderson admitted regretting that his Yankee career wasn't longer. His manager with the A's and  ...