Submit a Story!

Instant Replay Debate: The 5 Minute Home Run

 
Well, Instant Replay, you got one right. Last night, against the Minnesota Twins, Carlos Pena of the Tampa Bay Rays launched a home run that was called on the field as 'fan interference' . The fan interference play was ruled a double, Pena was awarded second base and Eric Hinske would have crossed home plate with Akinori Iwamura moving to third. The 'double' was overturned and Pena was justly rewarded with a home run. As it stands, Instant Replay has overturned one play, in three reviews. While FOX, TBS, and ESPN would clamor for a .333 hitter despite its other statistics, we all know there is more to a picture of a player then his batting average. That is, instant replay is not one for three.  It is, for all intents and purposes, one for one. However, what has it done to the game? In the two previous occasions the umpires made the correct call. The first, occurring in Tampa, as Alex Rodriguez's home run was confirmed , and as I mentioned previously , had no real affect on the ... (link)

Tags:

Related Content
Rays clinch first-ever playoff berth (AP)
sports.yahoo.com 9/21/2008 — The Tampa Bay Rays kept things simple, clinching the first playoff berth in franchise history on their own. Carlos Pena hit a two-run double and Scott Kazmir rebounded from the worst start of his career to pitch six scoreless innings Saturday, ...
Yankee Stadium, the final day
bugsandcranks.com 9/21/2008 — I did my ‘ Yankee Stadium memories ‘ post the other day. With today being the final day at the Cathedral of Baseball, however, let’s look around and see how others are commemorating the day. Yankee Stadium can’t speak ...
Congrats
letsgosox.blogspot.com 9/21/2008 — First, congrats to Sam Killay--the only Rays fan (though he also was a Sox fan) I ever was really aware of. He was a commenter in this blog's early days ("male Sam" as opposed to " female Sam "). Your team actually made the playoffs--though I kinda ...
The Home Run
mypinstripes.blogspot.com 9/21/2008
Opening Day 2009
outincenterfield.com 9/21/2008 — The 2008 season hasn't even wrapped up yet - there's still loads of September ball to played, not to mention the crucial month of October - but that doesn't stop the Red Sox front office from gearing up for 2009: the 2009 schedule has been released . ...
Rays left with memory of celebrationMajor League Baseball News 9/21/2008
Thanks to the hard work -- and well thought-out plan -- by Rays equipment manager Chris Westmoreland and crew, one would be hard pressed to find any lingering remnants of Saturday night's playoff-clinching celebration.
"Rays Clinch Playoff Birth, but Can They Get Anywhere in the Postseason?"Bleacher Report - MLB 9/21/2008
The 2008 season has been a crazy one, to say the least. A season filled with surprises, competition, and team breakdowns. I think we could all agree on the biggest surprise of the year—The Tampa Bay Rays. Over the past few years, ...
Piniella praises playoff-bound RaysMajor League Baseball News 9/21/2008
While Lou Piniella was being doused with champagne on Saturday by his current team, the Chicago Cubs, his former team, the Tampa Bay Rays, were celebrating their first postseason berth as well.
Remembering first trip to the StadiumBlogging the Bombers - NY Daily News Blogs 9/21/2008
The first time I ever set foot in Yankee Stadium was on May 5, 1979. My father took me to the Bronx to see the Yankees take on the A’s, just a few blocks from the apartment he grew up in. I don’t remember many details of the day, ...
Rays Clinch Playoff Berth, but Can They Get Anywhere in the Postseason?Bleacher Report - MLB 9/21/2008
The 2008 season has been a crazy one, to say the least. A season filled with surprises, competition, and team breakdowns. I think we could all agree on the biggest surprise of the year—The Tampa Bay Rays. Over the past few years, ...