Submit a Story!
Get the BallHype iPhone App
Baseball | Deserving Halladay won't win Cy
MLB AWARD PREVIEW AL CY YOUNG FAVOURITE Cliff Lee, Indians, 22-3, 2.54 ERA Coming off 5-8 and 6.29 in 2007, was 6-0 and 0.67 through first seven starts. ERA second in majors to Johan Santana's 2.53. CONTENDERS Roy Halladay, Jays, 20-11, 2.78 ERA Eleven losses does not look good but offence ...
Cliff Lee wins 2008 AL Cy Young Award
Cliff Lee wins 2008 AL Cy Young Award
mlb.mlb.com — Lee led the AL in wins with a 22-3 record and in ERA with a 2.54 mark... (more) Cliff Lee wins 2008 AL Cy Young Award
 Tim Lincecum of San Francisco Giants wins National League Cy Young Award
Tim Lincecum of San Francisco Giants wins National League Cy Young Award
sports.espn.go.com — NEW YORK -- Tim Lincecum won the National League Cy Young Award by a comfortable margin Tuesday,... taking home pitching's highest honor in his second major league season. The slender kid with the whirling windup joined Mike McCormick (1967) as the only ... (more) Tim Lincecum of San Francisco Giants wins National ...
Cliff Lee wins the 2008 AL Cy Young Award
sports.espn.go.com — Demoted to the minors last year, Lee went a major league-best 22-3 this season with a 2.54... ERA for the Cleveland Indians. (more) Cliff Lee wins the 2008 AL Cy Young Award
Comments
Blog Reactions

Open Cliff Lee Just Won the Cy Young Award Thread
Let's Go Tribe! — ... For a good laugh, head over to this article which explains why Roy Halladay is the deserving Cy Young winner.  Listen, I've heard the discussion several times.  There's no doubt that Halladay is a better pitcher but Cliff Lee just had a better year.  You can't fault someone for competition or what they would have done.  Or can you?  Anyway, the best part of the article: ...

Lee, Halladay really performed equally well
ESPN Feed: neyer rob — Our old friend Richard Griffin previews today's big announcement … Griffin next lays out his five arguments for Halladay over Lee. They're mostly nonsensical, including this gem: "Removing the stat lines from Halladay's six worst starts (an average of one per month), he was 19-7, with a 1.88 ERA in 191 1/3 innings." Well, yes. And if we remove Cliff Lee's six worst starts ( also an average of one per month), he was 19-1 with a 1.59 ERA. Columnists love to apply statistical tests, but they sometimes forget the necessary second step, which is to apply the tests fairly. ...

Cliff Lee caps improbable season with a Cy Young award
Big League Stew — ... In Lee, we got a bit of a different and somehow even more remarkable story. A year removed from what could have been a derailing stint in the minors, Lee returned to Cleveland and put up numbers (22-3, 2.54 ERA) that forced the otherwise-deserving Roy Halladay (20-11, 2.78) to settle for only four of the 28 first-place votes. Throw in the facts that Lee did it for a team that didn't have much of a chance of winning on days he didn't pitch and that he won his award the same week of Herb Score's passing and it's a cool story all the way around.  ...

Three Idiots Leave Halladay Off Their Cy Young Ballot
Drunk Jays Fans — ... clearly better. But no, three people left Halladay off the ballot in favour of either Matsuzaka, Mussina, Rivera, or fucking Ervin Santana. And though it's true that all of those guys had great seasons, come the fuck on. Come the fuck on. And I'm not even ranting on about this because I think it's a slight to Halladay or an affront to the team I support or anything like that-- I just think it's genuinely fucking stupid. Incidentally, we know that Doc had Richard Griffin's vote-- but do we know that Rob Neyer ripped Griff ...

Related Content
Halladay Wins Hearts, but not Cy Young
thebluejayhunter.blogspot.com 11/14/2008 — He had us at the first pitch on opening day. Start to finish this season, we knew that Roy Halladay would contend for the Cy Young award. But unfortunately, nobody planned for Cliff Lee coming out of nowhere and putting up a Cy Young-winning season.
AL Cy Young
phanamanda.blogspot.com 11/14/2008 — Cliff Lee wins the AL Cy Young Award
A.L. Cy Young Award--Cliff Lee the likely winner
mvn.com 11/15/2008 — 7:35 A.M.--The Cy Young Award will be awarded tomorrow at 2:00 P.M. The Cleveland Indians' Cliff Lee appears to be the clear frontrunner after going 22-3 with a 2.54 ERA. Lee led the A.L. in both wins and ERA. Toronto's Roy Halladay has been gaining moment over the past several weeks after having
Oh, what a difference a year makes: Cliff Lee wins the 2008 A.L. Cy Young Award
mvn.com 11/15/2008 — Cleveland Indians' lefty ace Cliff Lee was named the A.L. Cy Young award winner by the Baseball Writers' Association of America. Lee became the second Indians' lefty in as many years to win the Cy Young after the hefty lefty, CC Sabathia won the award last season. The irony is that Sabathia ...
Cliff, Meet Cy. Cy, Meet Cliff.
waitingfornextyear.com 11/13/2008 — Well, it’s official, after weeks of speculation. Cliff Lee is your 2008 American League Cy Young winner, beating Toronto’s Roy Halladay who finished second. Lee earned 24 of 28 first-place votes and 132 total points in voting done by the Baseball Writers’ Association of America. Halladay ...
Cliff Lee Wins 2008 AL Cy Young
soxanddawgs.com 11/13/2008 — Cliff Lee of the Cleveland Indians was named the winner of the 2008 AL Cy Young for his stellar season. He is the second straight member of the Indians to win the award, C.C. Sabathia won it last year.
Who You Got for the AL Cy? A B&C Argument
bugsandcranks.com 11/13/2008 — Cogent arguments for Cliff Lee, Roy Halladay, Matsuzaka, Francisco Rodriguez, and J. P. Howell.
American League Cy Young Award
mysportsrumors.com 11/13/2008 — In no surprise to anyone Cleveland Indians starter Cliff Lee was named the American League Cy Young Award Winner. Lee was so dominate during the season that the voting for this award wasn’t even close.
The Case for Roy Halladay
theoutsiderslook.blogspot.com 11/14/2008 — Brandon Heikoop discusses why Roy Halladay should have won the American League Cy Young award for the 2008 season. While he isn't completely opposed to Cliff Lee taking the hardware, there is enough evidence which shows Halladay being a superior choice.
2008 AL Cy Young Award
firenedcollettinow.com 10/17/2008 — I’ve already explained my thoughts on the current voters and my criteria in the NL Cy Young Award post, so go read it there if you need to. Since that's all the same for my AL Cy Young Award vote, i’ll cut right to chase in this post. The Frequently Mentioned And The Honorable ...
Cleveland lefty Lee wins AL Cy Young AwardNYDailyNews.com - Baseball 11/13/2008
Cliff Lee is a runaway winner for the AL Cy Young Award, capping a dominant comeback season that made him the second consecutive Cleveland Indians lefty to earn the honor. Lee went a major league-best 22-3 this season with a 2.54 ERA.  ...
Cliff Lee Climbs to Peak of Pitcher's Mound-ain, Receives A.L. Cy Young AwardBleacher Report - MLB 11/13/2008
When baseball writers ascended to the top of Mount Selig, slowly brought their collective hands to their mouths, and yodeled the name of Cleveland's Cliff Lee as the 2008 American League Cy Young Award winner, it marked the ...
Indians' Lee wins AL Cy Young Award (AP)Yahoo! Sports - MLB News 11/13/2008
Cliff Lee is a runaway winner for the American League Cy Young Award, capping a dominant comeback season that made him the second consecutive Cleveland Indians lefty to earn the honor. Demoted to the minors last year, Lee went a major league-best 22-3 ...
Rosenthal: Voters made right call on LeeFOXSports.com News for MLB 11/13/2008
While there was a case for Roy Halladay, Ken Rosenthal thinks voters got it right when they gave Cliff Lee the AL Cy Young.
Halladay runner-up in AL Cy Young voteMajor League Baseball News 11/13/2008
Though he finished runner-up to Cliff Lee in this year's AL Cy Young Award voting, the Blue Jays' Roy Halladay boasted quite a resume in his own right.