Submit a Story!
Get the BallHype iPhone App
BBWAA, Get Your Act Together!
Earlier this week, I poked some good-natured fun at the BBWAA for their Rookie of the Year award voting. See, Edinson Volquez of the Reds finished fourth in the balloting, yet he is not a rookie. Just because nobody heard of him prior to this year does not automatically deem him eligible as ...
Three Idiots Leave Halladay Off Their Cy Young Ballot
Three Idiots Leave Halladay Off Their Cy Young Ballot
drunkjaysfans.blogspot.com — Holy motherfucking fuck, people. Holy effing eff. What the fucking cock?... (more) Three Idiots Leave Halladay Off Their Cy Young Ballot
Who You Got for the AL Cy? A B&C Argument
Who You Got for the AL Cy? A B&C Argument
bugsandcranks.com — Cogent arguments for Cliff Lee, Roy Halladay, Matsuzaka, Francisco Rodriguez, and J. P. Howell.... (more) Who You Got for the AL Cy? A B&C Argument
Baseball | Deserving Halladay won't win Cy
thestar.com — MLB AWARD PREVIEW AL CY YOUNG FAVOURITE Cliff Lee, Indians, 22-3, 2.54 ERA Coming off 5-8 and... 6.29 in 2007, was 6-0 and 0.67 through first seven starts. ERA second in majors to Johan Santana's 2.53. CONTENDERS Roy Halladay, Jays, 20-11, 2.78 ERA ... (more) Baseball | Deserving Halladay won't win Cy
Comments
Blog Reactions

FanGraphs: Seidman: BBWAA, Get Your Act Together!
BBTF's Baseball Primer NewsblogFanGraphs: Seidman: BBWAA, Get Your Act Together! Ya’ know, Cootie Williams has always been considered a top notch sideman...but THIS Seidman solo is tough to beat. ARE YOU KIDDING ME? I mean, seriously, are you kidding me!? I don’t even care if Mariano Rivera had a much better season than K-Rod, or that Lester had a better year than Daisuke, or that Ervin Santana had a better year than BOTH Lester and Daisuke. No, what I care about is that three voters filled in a name under first place, second place, and third place, and none of those names were Roy Halladay. Three writers ...

Hey BBWAA
MVN RSS — ... in Geo Soto and Evan Longoria. However. it seems some writers who are part of the voting need a refresher on who is eligible to vote for.  The Reds pitcher Edinson Volquez recieved votes even though he is not Rookie eligible. ...

Friday Filberts
ESPN Feed: neyer rob — ... finished second in the Cy Young balloting, as he probably should have. It was a strong second. But apparently Halladay was completely ignored by three of the voters. And for FanGraphs' Eric Seidman, them's fightin' words . •Is there this much outrage about the award voting every year? I suppose a lot of it's because many voters actually write about voting; I don't believe this happened much until fairly recently. Anyway, Terry Pluto's taking some heat for being the Manager of the Year voter who kept Joe Maddon from winning unamimously, and ...

Philly Media Overreaction to MVP Results…
crashburnalley.com — ... For instance, Edinson Volquez, who had pitched 80 innings between 2005-07 and is clearly not a rookie, received three second-place votes for NL Rookie of the Year. Brandon Webb undeservedly received 73 total points in the NL Cy Young voting, behind winner Tim Lincecum’s 137. The most offensive result, though, was the 308 total points — including 37.5% of the first-place votes — given to Ryan Howard. Albert Pujols won, of course, but it should have been unanimous. If you haven’t read Eric Seidman’s rant against the BBWAA , hop on over to FanGraphs. I’m not going to spend too ...

Roy Halladay: Ace, Cornerstone, Player of Little Value
Ghostrunner on First — ... awards; alternately awarded for outstanding performance and contribution to a winning or playoff team. Warts and all, it's a pretty big deal. There are significant performance bonuses attached to the voting, so when it becomes a hilarious farce, I get upset. Earlier this month, Roy Halladay placed second in the American League Cy Young voting. Disappointing as it may be, Cliff Lee had a great year. The back-and-forth over strength of schedule etc. makes for good reading and discussion, so I'm all for it. Francisco Rodriquez didn't ...

Related Content
A Day in the Life Existence of Roy Halladay
ghostrunneronfirst.com 11/28/2008 — It is widely acknowledged that Roy Halladay is equal parts man, animal, and machine. His ravenous appetite for the flesh of opponents is offset by his laser-like execution of a precise, predetermined strategy and his unfailing humility. Basically, ...
Roy Halladay: Ace, Cornerstone, Player of Little Value
ghostrunneronfirst.com 11/19/2008 — Hey look! The midget with the punchable face won the MVP! Good for him, debatable but not fire-bombable. The MVP is the most nebulous of all the post-season awards; alternately awarded for outstanding performance and contribution to a winning or ...
Daisuke Matsuzaka & BABIP
lookoutlanding.com 10/11/2008 — Lately - especially in light of yesterday's performance - there's been a lot of talk about Daisuke Matsuzaka's ability to strand runners and get out of jams. To carry at 2.90 ERA with those kinds of peripherals is no small feat, and his .225 BABIP ...
Andrew Dice-K
bleacherreport.com 12/14/2008 — Consider the following two pitchers: The first pitcher throws 204 2/3 innings, striking out 201 and walking 80, while surrendering 25 home runs and 191 hits and posting an ERA of 4.40. The second pitcher yields half as many home runs, as well as ...
: Business of Sports Network
bizofbaseball.com 11/13/2008 — Mike Dee The following audio interview (MP3) is with Mike Dee, the president of Fenway Sports Group. ( play the interview below ) Dee was also named as Red Sox Chief Operating Officer March 7, 2004, less than 2 years after he joined the club as ...
Post Season Awards Coming Cliff’s Way
waitingfornextyear.com 10/21/2008 — For Cliff Lee, hopefully this is only the beginning. The salad and bread before the main course is served. Lee already won the AL’s comeback player of the year award, and this weekend he picked up two more honors. Lee was voted Most Outstanding Pitcher by the player’s association as
The Case for Roy Halladay
theoutsiderslook.blogspot.com 11/14/2008 — Brandon Heikoop discusses why Roy Halladay should have won the American League Cy Young award for the 2008 season. While he isn't completely opposed to Cliff Lee taking the hardware, there is enough evidence which shows Halladay being a superior choice.
: Business of Sports Network
bizofbaseball.com 12/2/2008 — Mike Dee The following audio interview (MP3) is with Mike Dee, the president of Fenway Sports Group. ( play the interview below ) Dee was also named as Red Sox Chief Operating Officer March 7, 2004, less than 2 years after he joined the club as ...
WEEI 850AM Sports Radio - One Pitcher Who Was Actually Worth the Money
weei.com 11/17/2008 — Did anybody notice that Daisuke Matsuzaka was deemed the fourth-best pitcher in the American League for the 2008 season by those casting ballots for the Cy Young Award? Were you paying attention to the reality that the Red Sox starter had a 5-1 ...
Baseball Play Log
fangraphs.com 10/17/2008 — Scoreboard Game Graphs Play Log Box Score Rays @ Red Sox (281016102) 10/16/2008 - Rays(7) @ Red Sox(8) Pitcher Player Inn. Outs Base Score Play LI RE WE WPA BRAA D Matsuzaka A Iwamura 1 0 ___ 0-0 Single 0.87 0.53 46.5 % .035 0.39 D Matsuzaka B Upton ...
Rosenthal: Voters made right call on LeeFOXSports.com News for MLB 11/13/2008
While there was a case for Roy Halladay, Ken Rosenthal thinks voters got it right when they gave Cliff Lee the AL Cy Young.
Halladay runner-up in AL Cy Young voteMajor League Baseball News 11/13/2008
Though he finished runner-up to Cliff Lee in this year's AL Cy Young Award voting, the Blue Jays' Roy Halladay boasted quite a resume in his own right.
Doc Halladay a Distant Second in Cy Young Voting: Indian Lee WinsBleacher Report - MLB 11/14/2008
A long shot at best, Roy "Doc" Halladay came up short in the 2008 AL Cy Young award voting by the Baseball Writers Association of America. In probably his best MLB season ever, Halladay was overshadowed this year by Cliff Lee of the Cleveland ...
Cleveland's Cliff Lee wins AL Cy YoungL.A. Times - Baseball News 11/14/2008
Toronto's Roy Halladay finishes a distant second. Angels' Francisco Rodriguez is third. > Cliff Lee won the American League Cy Young Award in a runaway Thursday, capping a dominant ...
Jays Halladay a Distant Second in Cy Young Voting: Indian Lee WinsBleacher Report - MLB 11/14/2008
A long shot at best, Roy "Doc" Halladay came up short in the 2008 AL Cy Young award voting by the Baseball Writers Association of America. In probably his best MLB season ever, Halladay was overshadowed this year by Cliff Lee of the Cleveland ...