Submit a Story!
Get the BallHype iPhone App
BCS For Dummies (no, really)

Did you know that division one college football is the only college sport that doesn’t have a playoff system? If you follow college football, then you are already aware of this travesty. College football’s Bowl Championship Series (BCS) system needs to be changed because in many situations, there is not a clear-cut national champion, and is unfair to mid-major and smaller conferences. The current BCS is conspired by a set of computers that take many things into account in deciding who is number one, two and so on. The BCS takes in strength of schedule, wins, amount by which you won the game, and other things to determine who will play in five games, the National Championship, Rose Bowl, Sugar Bowl, Orange Bowl and the Fiesta Bowl. The six biggest conferences, 66 teams, always have a set spot in the BCS system as their conference winner will always have a spot in a BCS game. One slot is set aside for ‘non BCS’ schools, such as the Mountain West Conference. The system is too complicated and shows a brighter side to, “human error.”

The BCS system does not work properly as it does not determine an undisputed national champion consistently, and leaves deserving teams out of a chance for a national title. In 2004 the LSU Tigers went 13-1 and at the end of the postseason they were ranked # 1 in the coaches poll. But that same year, the USC Trojans went 13-0, and were ranked # 1 in the Associated Press Poll. This means that there was a tie as who was the national champion that year. There cant be a tie in the national championship, right?

In 2007 the Boise State Broncos went undefeated during the regular season and then went on to beat an Adrian Peterson led Oklahoma Sooners in one of the best games in college football history. At 13-0, they got at least a share of the national title right? Absolutely not. Poor Boise State was cheated out of a national championship share-let alone an entire title-because a series of computers didn’t like their “strength of schedule”. Boise State player’s coaches and fans were left wondering

Another case was handed to us just this year. Utah beat four ranked teams, crushing Alabama, and still did not have a chance to be champs. Utes quarterback Brian Johnson said, “What else could we have done?” The answer is to change conferences; it is the only way a mid-major school will EVER win a national championship in college football, with the current BCS system. Sorry Boise State, sorry Utah but your not in an exclusive club called “66 of 119: Were just better”. These are all great examples why the system is flawed, and something needs to be changed.

If the system is so bad, why hasn’t it been changed already? How would they go about a playoff system? The BCS hasn’t been removed due to the revenue and ignorance of university presidents. They receive great amounts of money for their university with television contracts and overall revenue that the game brings. The BCS makes over 100 millions dollars annually on the five games played, with that number growing each year. The NCAA, the BCS heads, major university presidents, network television heads and conference commissioners would have to meet for a very long time and work out the kinks in negotiations for this at all to be possible. These people really have no incentive to change, they have their money now, and they are happy with it, changing is scary, as they are not one hundred percent sure that they will get the same ridiculous amount.

There is still hope for a successful college football postseason. There has been calling by many for a college football playoff system, especially for the past few years now. Even President-Elect Barack Obama has showed support for the idea of a division I college football playoff system. A lot of talk has been made about this-but talk is easy. I believe that the best thing for college football fans, players, coaches, university presidents and television network heads is an eight game playoff system.

Why eight teams? Let’s be honest, sixteen teams would be too big of a time span and too many games would have to be played. It would be too overwhelming physically for teams to have to play that many games. I also think that it would be too big of a time span for these STUDENT-athletes, they would miss class. Eight teams is a perfect number of schools. Browsing over the last few years’ rankings after week fourteen, there is little dispute about who would be in the top eight.

A great thing about having eight teams is it is not too overwhelming for a school or its players. The playoffs are started the third week in December then the next two Saturdays, so it actually ends the season sooner that before, leaving time for students to prepare for the spring semester. I also think that this would end the interference college football encounters with the National Football Leagues playoffs.

The first four games are called whatever you like; I’d prefer the Rose, Sugar, Orange and Fiesta Bowls, for traditions sake. Then the two semi-final games can either be generic names, or they can be bought for millions of dollars by big corporations like the other bowls have been. This system creates extra revenue because of television contracts that help universities, the NCAA, and those same television networks. Another great thing about the system is that it actually determines a clear, undisputed national champion every single year, which is really the point of it all.

Another key point of the system would be is that there is no subjugation of conferences, meaning that whatever teams are the in the top eight after week fourteen, get into the playoff system. One dispute that I foresee with it is that the eighth ranked team that gets in may have some controversy. Some say that people will not travel to their team, which I disagree with completely. When the University of Wyoming got invited to the Las Vegas Bowl in 2004 against the UCLA Bruins, there were more Wyoming fans than there were UCLA fans. You cannot tell me that fans wouldn’t follow their team, especially if it is an exciting playoff system.

And don’t give me that garbage that “The integrity of the regular season would be lost.” Are you kidding me? Studying the previous years top 8 teams there is a bagel in the column where two loss teams are. That’s enough incentive to try and win every single game, or you have a big chance of not making the playoffs, hello Texas Tech. Youd don’t think thee schools want the number one seed? Look at the NCAA tourney last year, all number seeds (it matters). And you don’t think these kids have pride? Having an undefeated season is unbelievable experience for anybody, especially for the prominence it would bring to the schools. The regular season would not lose an ounce of veracity; teams have too much to play for.

College football’s postseason is in shambles. How do we begin to rebuild? With the eight team playoff systems I proposed earlier, there would be more games to be shown that are more television contracts, aka more money for everyone. Start off by implementing a playoff system that is attractive to not only fans, but network and university, and conference heads as well. As president elect Barack Obama would say, “YES WE CAN!”

We Need the BCS in the NFL!
We Need the BCS in the NFL!
sftsports.com — Quit griping about the playoff system in the NFL...it could be worse...it could be the BCS! (more) We Need the BCS in the NFL!
The Alphabetical: Bowl Edition
The Alphabetical: Bowl Edition
sportingnews.com — Spencer Hall offers a letter-by-letter analysis of the college football bowl season. A is for Ambiguity, Again, ARRRRGGGHH. If the BCS is not dead yet, it has been placed on a metal table, strapped down, and placed in the path of a slowly ... (more) The Alphabetical: Bowl Edition
Congressman plans hearings on BCS in effort to force playoff
usatoday.com — "I think you really do not get a true No. 1 out of (the Bowl Championship Series)," Rep. Edolphus Towns, D-N.Y., told USA TODAY. "Nobody questions the Super Bowl. The team that wins is the best team that year. I think we can do the same thing at the ... (more) Congressman plans hearings on BCS in effort to force ...
Comments
Related Content
A Detailed Look at the BCS System
bizoffootball.com 1/7/2009 — There is no other system that can stir up a conversation like the BCS, Bowl Championship Series . Does college football need a playoff, or is the BCS the best solution possible? Here's a detailed break down of the BCS system.
Is the BCS breaking any Anti-Trust Laws?
mwcfootball.wordpress.com 1/13/2009 — This all started when Utah Attorney General, Mark Shurtleff , said he would be suing the BCS just a few days after the Utes defeated Alabama 31-17 in the Sugar Bowl.
What Exactly Is A National Champion, Anyhow?
rockytoptalk.com 1/8/2009 — Musings from 37,000 feet en route to Knoxville. Having been delayed a day due to weather, I finally made the first leg of my journey home from Wyoming to Knoxville for the next semester.  Thanks to a pleasantly welcome 3-hour layover, I ...
Boycott the BCS Advertisers: Our Only Shot at Ever Ending the BCS [Clay Nation]
deadspin.com 12/18/2008 — Here’s one of my 2009 New Year’s Resolutions a couple of weeks early: I hereby resolve not to consume the products of any company that advertises during the BCS Games for the entire month of January. For purposes of this resolution consume is ...
Best BCS Conference? How About the ACC?
thewizofodds.com 1/15/2009 — Joe Giglio of the Raleigh News & Observer has finished his annual look at how Bowl Championship Series conferences fared in 2008, and if you're a fan of the Atlantic Coast Conference, you have something to brag about. The ACC won more games ...
A 7th BCS Conference? Not Yet.
spartyandfriends.com 1/27/2009 — The Mountain West Conference wants in. At least that’s what they are starting to tell the media, the other conferences, and anyone else who is willing to listen. The problem is, can you really award a conference the right to be among the nation’s elite after one season?
Video: I Love The BCS Song - Will Forte on Saturday Night Live's Weekend Update
sportsrubbish.blogspot.com 1/11/2009 — Will Forte's song about his love for the BCS
Mountain West to push BCS for guaranteed mid-major berth
fanblogs.com 2/22/2009 — I'm not sure if this is going to be the silver bullet, or just the most recent proposed change in the BCS, but it appears that the Mountain West Conference will propose an automatic berth in the BCS for the best mid-major school from the Conference ...
Mountain West pushing to gain BCS Entry
mwcfootball.wordpress.com 1/27/2009 — The USA Today is reporting that Mountain West Conference commissioner Craig Thompson wants to at least “put on the table” the idea that the Mountain West deserves and automatic bid to the BCS.
Ratings show addition of fifth BCS game a failure - Stewart Mandel - SI.com
sportsillustrated.cnn.com 1/5/2009 — Whenever BCS officials defend their oft-criticized postseason system, they like to point to the "overall health of college football," as measured by increased attendance and TV ratings. They're talking, however, about the regular season. In terms of ...
A Few Suggestions For The Next BCS CycleBleacher Report - College Football 1/13/2009
Following the 2010 BCS National Championship Game in Pasadena, the Bowl Championship Series will enter its fourth cycle as major college football’s premiere postseason entity.   And, as much as we whine, cry, plead, beg, threaten, ...
Five Suggestions for the Next BCS CycleBleacher Report - College Football 1/13/2009
Following the 2010 BCS National Championship Game in Pasadena, the Bowl Championship Series will enter its fourth cycle as major college football’s premier postseason entity.   And as much as we whine, cry, plead, beg, threaten, ...
I Love the BCS!Bleacher Report - College Football 1/14/2009
I dedicate this song to all those who oppose an FBS (Div. I-A) playoff. "I Love the BCS" (as sung by Will Forte on Saturday Night Live , Jan. 10, 2009) I love stepping in dog crap And I love it when children get sick I love paper cuts on ...
Why Utah Should Be College Football's Postseason No. 1Bleacher Report - College Football 1/14/2009
College football left us many great memories this last season, with last second touchdowns such as Michael Crabtree’s TD against Texas, and memorable rivalry games like Florida and Georgia.  This season also left us many questions.  ...
The Utah Utes Should Be College Football's Postseason No. 1Bleacher Report - College Football 1/14/2009
College football left us with many great memories this season—last second touchdowns such as Michael Crabtree’s TD against Texas and memorable rivalry games like Florida and Georgia.  This season also left us with many ...