Submit a Story!
Get the BallHype iPhone App
Votes
topics:

vote down flag
Despite Ian O'Connor's Worst Efforts, Ben Roethlisberger Is Still Better Than Eli Manning
nfl.fanhouse.com - 10/22/2008
Despite Ian O'Connor's Worst Efforts, Ben Roethlisberger Is Still Better Than Eli Manning
—
As I was doing my daily browsing of the Internet, searching for videos of cats playing ping-pong and water skiing squirrels, I stumbled upon this article from Ian O'Connor over at Fox Sports titled, "In a do-over, Eli still gets draft nod over Big Ben." My first thought was, "oh crap, not this ...
Eli vs. Ben: The case for Eli
bigblueview.com - 10/24/2008
Eli vs. Ben: The case for Eli
— bigblueview.com — [ EDITOR'S NOTE: Since 'Blitz' has posted his 'Case for Ben' over on Behind the Steel Curtain... I figured I would also put my 'case for Eli' up here.] Let me start by saying this -- Ben Roethlisberger is a tremendous quarterback, probably one of the ... (more) Eli vs. Ben: The case for Eli

Comments vote down FanHouse found this 10/24/2008found this
behindthesteelcurtain.com - 10/24/2008
Eli Manning vs. Ben Roethlisberger: The Case For Ben
— behindthesteelcurtain.com — Giants fans seem to be tending to other matters this morning, so I'm going to post this... here to see what Steelers fans think of my assessment that Ben might have struggled had he been subjected to the pressures of New York.. The fun debate is ... (more) Eli Manning vs. Ben Roethlisberger: The Case For Ben

Comments vote down Amazin' Avenue found this 10/24/2008found this
msn.foxsports.com - 10/22/2008
FOX Sports on MSN - NFL - In a do-over, Eli still gets draft nod over Big Ben
— msn.foxsports.com — In fact, when the Steelers and Giants meet Sunday in Pittsburgh, Roethlisberger will carry the following career... advantages over Manning to the center of the field: More touchdown passes (93 to 85); fewer interceptions (57 to 68); a higher completion ... (more) FOX Sports on MSN - NFL - In a do-over, Eli still gets ...

Comments vote down FanHouse found this 10/22/2008found this

Blog Reactions

Heels, Sox & Steelers:  ELISHA > little ben (Obviously)

Kissing Suzy Kolber:  Class of the ‘04 Tards: Large Benjamin vs. Bitter Elisha. WHO YA GOT?

Comments
Blog Reactions

ELISHA > little ben (Obviously)
Heels, Sox & Steelers — ... You won't like Dr. Gretz when he's angry.

Class of the ‘04 Tards: Large Benjamin vs. Bitter Elisha. WHO YA GOT?
Kissing Suzy Kolber — ... . Since then, each has picked up his own piece of hardware (and by that, I don’t mean the metal plate in Ben’s head) and has for the most part shed his once reductive reputation (Ben: He’s a game manager! Eli: He fucking sucks!). Will this game finally settle who was the class of that draft? I’m a Steelers fan and even I don’t give a shit. But maybe you do. So, WHO YA GOT? ...

Related Content
Eli Manning vs. Ben Roethlisberger: The Case For Eli
behindthesteelcurtain.com 10/23/2008 — The following is Ed Valentine's take on who he would rather have as his QB - Ben Roethlisberger or Eli Manning. Ed writes the popular Giants blog Big Blue View . My case for Big Ben should appear on his site sometime tomorrow. -Blitz- [ EDITOR'S ...
Who's No. 1: Ben or Eli?
nydailynews.com 10/26/2008 — In the days leading up to the 2004 NFL draft, Ernie Accorsi wanted Eli Manning, but until the very end, he never believed he would get him. The former Giants GM was sure he was going to end up with Ben Roethlisberger.
Giants v. Steelers and Eli v. Ben
the-steelyard.blogspot.com 10/26/2008 — A Steelers' blog predicts the outcome of the game and weighs in on whether Eli is really now better than Ben.
Top 10 reasons Big Ben is better than Eli Manning
steelerstoday.com 10/23/2008 — A detailed head-to-head comparison of Ben Roethlisberger and Eli Manning.
Eli Manning, Giants surge to beat Steelers and Ben Roethlisberger, 21-14
nydailynews.com 10/27/2008 — BY RALPH VACCHIANO DAILY NEWS SPORTS WRITER Sunday, October 26th 2008, 6:51 PM PITTSBURGH - The game was billed as a Super Bowl preview, but the Giants preferred to think of it as heavyweight fight. They knew they were going to take some punches ...
ELI, BIG BEN READY TO DUEL
nypost.com 10/23/2008 — It sure sounds as if Ben Roethlisberger is glad he's not Eli Manning, content he's doing his thing in Pittsburgh and not New York. "I don't mind where I'm at," Roethlisberger said yesterday. "I don't want to be out there like that. Football is...
In a do-over, Eli still gets draft nod over Big Ben
msn.foxsports.com 10/23/2008 — Eli Manning was picked ahead of Ben Roethlisberger in the 2004 draft. Given a mulligan, Ian O'Connor would still take Archie's boy first.
Exclusive Interview With Ben Roethlisberger
kdka.com 10/29/2008 — PITTSBURGH (KDKA) ― It's been five years since Ben Roethlisberger took Pittsburgh by storm. A lot has happened for him since he first took the field here, but one of the biggest things might be what's happening this season, getting to have a larger ...
ROETHLISBERGER IS DAY TO DAY
profootballtalk.com 11/4/2008 — Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger had to leave last night’s game against the Redskins, but the early indications are that he’ll be ready to go Sunday against the Colts. Adam Schefter of NFL Network reports that preliminary tests of ...
Give Eli Manning His Due
bleacherreport.com 12/2/2008 — I am a die-hard Eagles fan and I admit I can be a little biased at times. Who isn't? And I hate the Giants and Cowboys, like every other Philly guy.   I hate all the big-name guys: Romo, Eli, T.O., Plax, Roy Williams, and so on. I feel most ...
Eli shrugs off Class of '04 comparisons — The Blue Screen - NY Daily News Blogs 10/22/2008
It's a Class of '04 reunion at Heinz Field this Sunday, when Eli Manning and Ben Roethlisberger will meet on the field for the first time since December 18, 2004. The comparisons between the two are, of course, inevitable. And there's really no ...
Favre tackles Lion Gate — The Jet Stream - NY Daily News Blogs 10/22/2008
An unusually large media swarm made its way out to Florham Park today to listen to Brett Favre. No, the media types didn’t come out to hear his take on the Chiefs’ defense. This was all about Lion Gate. Or is it Lyin’ Gate? Favre ...
Roethlisberger & Eli have Ben there — NYDailyNews.com - Football 10/23/2008
Four years after being part of the same draft class, as the Eli Manning and Ben Roethlisberger prepare to square off again, the comparisons are a more pleasant for Manning - especially since they can now compare Super Bowl rings.
Ross Tucker: Favre, Winslow put themselves in precarious situations — SI.com - NFL 10/23/2008
It's pretty simple, says Ross Tucker: Brett Favre was out of line talking to the Lions about the Packers.
Roethlisberger or Manning: Who's Better? A Nine Year Old Provides Some Answers — Bleacher Report - NFL 10/23/2008
Pittsburgh Steeler Ben Roethlisberger and Indianapolis Colt Peyton Manning began their NFL careers as starters. Both have won Super Bowls. Both have been league MVPs. But who’s the better quarterback? In most ways, both quarterbacks are ...