Submit a Story!
Get the BallHype iPhone App
Manager Joe Girardi should be fired if the New York Yankees lose to Los Angeles Angels in ALCS
Manager Joe Girardi should be fired if the New York Yankees lose to Los Angeles Angels in ALCS
The Yankees will come home Saturday still leading the ALCS, 3-2, still one win away from returning to the World Series for the first time since 2003, still with Andy Pettitte and CC Sabathia lined up to pitch them there. But let's get this out of the way now, so it's not a reactionary thing if ...
ALCS: That Game Was Ridiculous
ALCS: That Game Was Ridiculous
babeslovebaseball.com — Holy smokes, now that was a poorly-managed ball game. The Los Angeles Angels kept their World Series... dreams alive for one more night, coming away with a 7-6 win over the New York Yankees in Game 5 of the ALCS Thursday night in what turned out to be a helluva baseball game... (more) ALCS: That Game Was Ridiculous
Quality Start: My Manager Is Dumber Than Yours
Quality Start: My Manager Is Dumber Than Yours
majorleaguejerk.com — Barring some kind of dramatic HR in a clinching game or a fluketastic pitching performance like Jack... Morris’, years from now when we look back on the 2009 MLB playoffs, the two things we’re going to remember most about them are the ... (more) Quality Start: My Manager Is Dumber Than Yours
Coffee Joe extends ALCS
Coffee Joe extends ALCS
pinstripedbible.mlblogs.com — Despite getting some things in Game 5 that seemed impossible just hours and minutes before they happened... --- big hits from Mark Teixeira and (holy cow) Robinson Cano -- Joe Girardi helped pay back a terrific Yankees rally by once... (more) Coffee Joe extends ALCS
Comments
Blog Reactions

The Yankee Way
Never on Injured Reserve — ... in Alfredo Aceves in the eleventh inning of game three after David Robertson had only thrown eleven pitches and gotten two quick outs. Aceves imploded, allowing the game winning run to score. Yesterday, some would argue that leaving A.J. Burnett in the game to pitch the seventh inning was a mistake and the Angels ended up winning that one as well. But how big of a mistake will both of those decisions end up being if the Angels win both games in the Bronx this weekend? To quote New York Daily News reporter Jesse Spector, "after failing to guide a $200 million team to October ...

Friday Night Open Thread: If Yanks choke this away should Girardi be fired?
Sliding Into Home: A Yankees BlogJesse Spector of the Daily News wrote about this today, and I think he has a point. Spector isn't saying the Yankees will blow it, but if they do he thinks Girardi should go. Besides the terrible managerial decisions he's made that have directly led to the Yanks losing two games this series Spector points out the historic aspect of this and how most teams don't recover from such choke jobs, especially not with the same manager at the helm. Here's more from Spector: ...

Getting Antsy In New York
Blak4rest: Sports, Media and Vegas — ... Joe Girardi has gotten plenty of criticisms over his pitching decisions (or lack of) during the AL playoffs. Jesse Spector says if the Yankees, who lead the ALCS 3-2, blow this series to the Angels, Girardi should be fired. You think? Only in New York. N.Y. Daily News

Will It Be Deja Vu All Over Again in the Big Apple?
Boston Dirt Dogs — ... Things Are Going to Get Tight for A-Rod and Company on Saturday Night Torii Hunter: 'All the Pressure is On the Yankees' NY Daily News: Girardi Should Be Fired if Yankees Lose to Angels OC Register: How Can the Angels Win in New York? ...

…. It’s a mistake
Only Baseball Matters — ... How is that sequence even remotely defensible? I’ve been looking all day, and am still waiting for the dozens of articles question the choices Girardi made in that inning. Here’s one, from Jesse Spector, of the NY Daily News: ...

Should Girardi be fired if Yanks blow it?
Circling The Bases — I hate off-days during the playoffs. It's mind-numbingly boring. It makes the mind wander. It makes otherwise rational people, like Jesse Spector of the Daily News, write articles like this : The Yankees will come home Saturday still leading the ALCS, 3-2, still one win away from returning to the World Series for the first time since 2003, still with Andy Pettitte and CC Sabathia lined up to pitch them there. But let's get this out of the way now, so it's not a reactionary thing if the Yankees lose their sixth and seventh consecutive games with the American League pennant ...

Girardi's quandry
SULLY BASEBALL — ... was dreadful in the post season prior to this year. There could be a pitchers duel… or a battle of the bullpens. So let’s say the Angels win a Game 6 started by Sabathia. They would have insane confidence going into Game 7… the Yankees would be pressing and the Game 7 pitching match up of John Lackey vs. Andy Pettitte would favor Los Angeles… or California… or Anaheim… or Los Angeles of Anaheim. And isn’t this over managing exactly what has Girardi in the crosshairs of the fan base’s ire? And if Sabathia DOES win Game 6 on Sunday, he would not be ...

How'd we get here: Fatalistic Yanks fans
It's About The Money - A New York Yankees Blog — With the MSM already calling for Girardi's head before Game 6 even takes place, I'm left to wonder how we, as Yanks fans, came to be so fatalistic. Taking a brief trip in the way-back machine, there was a sense of calm during the Yanks 1990's run to four titles. When we lost a game, even the opening two games, there wasn't the sense of panic that seems to now envelop those covering the team. I'll admit that this could just be a selective memory thing from me, but why are the media (and the blogosphere) so quick to bury the Yanks despite ...

How'd we get here: Fatalistic Yanks fans (REDUX)
It's About The Money - A New York Yankees Blog — The original posting was written before Game 6 of the ALCS against the Angels. What you see below is an updated version, updated for the World Series and the Phillies links, but little else. -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=   With the MSM already calling for Girardi's head before Game 6 even takes place (and lunkheads like me questioning his decisions), I'm left to wonder how we, as Yanks fans, came to be so fatalistic.  [I also wonder if it's merely the local media looking to ...

What They're Saying: Joe Girardi
No, You're a Towel — ... Bryant says that as we move on to Game 6, the focus is on the decisions the managers have made Rob Neyer says that Girardi's biggest mistake in Game 5 was pinch running for A-Rod  GQ writes that while the action on the field was compelling, the managing decisions of Game 5 were puzzling  RealClearSports says that Girardi is making mistakes by not relying on instincts Jesse Spector says that if the Yankees somehow lose the ALCS, Joe Girardi should be fired  ...

Related Content
Friday Night Open Thread: If Yanks choke this away should Girardi be fired?
slidingintohome.blogspot.com 10/24/2009 — Jesse Spector of the Daily News wrote about this today, and I think he has a point. Spector isn't saying the Yankees will blow it, but if they do he thinks Girardi should go. Besides the terrible managerial decisions he's made that have directly led to the Yanks losing two games this series ...
ALCS Preview: A tale of two managers
riveraveblues.com 10/14/2009 — When the Yankees and the Angels begin their ALCS series on Friday, the coverage on FOX is sure to center around the two men leading these teams. Mike Scioscia and Joe Girardi have a lot in common. They were both defensive-minded catchers known for ...
Girardi’s Over Managing Costs Yanks
nybaseballdigest.com 10/20/2009 — It’s hard to put into words how incredibly furious I was at Joe Girardi last night after the Yankees loss to Anaheim. Almost immediately after the game, I called Mike Silva, leaving a message which showed my sheer displeasure in how Girardi mismanaged the bullpen. Girardi’s use of ...
Joe Girardi Overmanages, Angels Take Game Three
theghostofmoonlightgraham.wordpress.com 10/20/2009 — If you are going to be uptight, nervous, and overmanage in the postseason, you better win. Time and time again, New York Yankees manager has overmanaged in this postseason and the Yankees' talent has bailed him out. Today, there was nobody to bail Girardi out.
What They're Saying: Joe Girardi
noyoureatowel.net 10/25/2009 — Joe Girardi has been praised at times this postseason, but has been criticized more often. Has he really been doing a bad job or are people overreacting to a few losses? Let's see what everyone has to say:   AOL Fanhouse goes over Girardi's decisions in Game 3 to try to figure out ...
Joe Girardi's overmanaging cost Yankees in ALCS Game 3 - Tom Verducci - SI.com
sportsillustrated.cnn.com 10/21/2009 — 1. The Yankees are still in command of the ALCS. They give the ball on Tuesday night to a red-hot CC Sabathia , and, given that the Angels have no one like Sabathia, Mariano Rivera or Alex Rodriguez , New York is still likely to win the series. Joe ...
Girardi’s gaff costs Yankees in Game 3 of ALCS
scoresreport.com 10/20/2009 — The Angels avoided falling in a three-game hole by beating the Yankees 5-4 in Game 3 of the ALCS on Monday night. Vladimir Guerrero hit a game-tying two-run home run in the sixth inning and Jeff Mathis hit a game-winning RBI double in the bottom of the 11th inning for the Halos. Not to ...
Ripping On Girardi Now The “In” Thing To Do
theyankeeuniverse.com 28 days ago — Joe Girardi may be the first manager to guide his team to 103 wins and the World Series to spend the entire time prior to the Series getting skewered by the press. First it was Jon Heyman : Girardi apparently already has a dreary book of ...
Were the Yankee sac bunts in the 8th inning correct?
fangraphs.com 29 days ago — The answer to that question is complicated. There is no easy yes or no answer and that is not so much because there are so many variables we don’t know the answer. It has to do with game theory. Oh, in case you didn’t watch the 6th game of the ...
Joe Girardi: Overmanager of the year?
subwaysquawkers.blogspot.com 10/20/2009 — It's all your fault, Joe. The Yankees should have won today's ALCS game, and they would have had a great chance at doing so, if Joe Girardi had left well enough alone. I think Girardi has done a terrific job overall this year, but his relentless overmanaging of the bullpen cost the Yankees the ...
$200M Payroll + No World Series Title = Failed Season For YankeesBleacher Report - MLB 10/23/2009
The 2009 New York Yankees came into the regular season with a lot of hope and promise. They splurged big time in their off-season by signing ace CC Sabathia, another ace in A.J. Burnett, and slugging first basemen Mark Teixeira. This was beginning ...
Girardi sticking with Pettitte despite weatherMajor League Baseball News 10/24/2009
Game 6 of the ALCS is scheduled to start at 7:57 p.m. ET on Saturday, and Yankees manager Joe Girardi said Friday that Andy Pettitte will be his starting pitcher whether that game is played or whether forecasted thunderstorms force a postponement to ...
Swish and a missBlogging the Bombers - NY Daily News Blogs 10/24/2009
The big news out of the Yankees workout today was whether or not Nick Swisher, struggling mightily in the postseason, will be in the lineup tomorrow night for Game 6. Joe Girardi said he was going to "sleep on it and we'll make a decision what we're ...
Harper: Skippers, bullpens will decide Game 6NYDailyNews.com - Baseball 10/24/2009
Their respective bullpens have left burn marks all over Joe Girardi and Mike Scioscia, and now, the way the managers deal with the pain figures to go a long way toward determining the winner between the Yankees and the Angels.
Pettitte ready to KO AngelsNYDailyNews.com - Baseball 10/24/2009
Andy Pettitte did not want to be in the interview room at Angel Stadium late Thursday night, discussing his upcoming Game 6 start in the ALCS. Still, Pettitte has a chance to pitch the Yankees into the World Series.