Playoff Dispatches, Part Four

4
0
Votes
Playoff Dispatches, Part Four Links4
Black Shoe Diaries: Front Page Posts found this 2/21/2007 on www.dawgsports.com [flag]
There can be little doubt that, of the numerous perennial debates that divide college football fans, the most heated is the question of whether a Division I-A playoff ought to be implemented. Sunday Morning Quarterback and I agreed to tackle this... [link]

Tags:

Comments

Links (4)

Nitt Picks
Published 2/21/2007 by Mike at Black Shoe Diaries: Front Page Posts
... Part IV

Playoff Dispatches with DawgSports , Part Five
Published 2/21/2007 by SMQ at Sunday Morning Quarterback: Front Page Posts
... in turn why there is any problem with the `legitimacy' of a playoff winner as champion. Kyle responds by reiterating his preference for judging performance over many games rather than automatically rewarding success in a few. Here, SMQ gets very fundamental:

The Debate: Retired players
Published 2/23/2007 by Skin Patrol at Hogs Haven: Front Page Posts
... (as proponent of playoffs) and Kyle of Dawg Sports (against). Having acknowledged that great debate -- which I encourage all Hogs Haven reader(s) who are also CFB fans to familiarize themselves -- I move on to a matter prevalent to Redskins fans as NFL fans.

Pound Pound Pound: The 2007 Playoff Post
Published 12/19/2007 by SMQ <info@sundaymorningqb.com> at Sunday Morning Quarterback: Front Page Posts
... will, after a brief debacle with the "pus one" compromise, and will grow quickly to the grossest, most unwieldy proportions), or any kind of specific format. They're all brilliant plans, in the sense that any playoff = brilliant relative to the Bowl Championship Series, which is, for the hundredth time, a flagrant corporate marketing cabal that hurts the sport. All of these arguments are tired and, from the opposition, ultimately failures. One argument against a playoff is valid - who needs a national champion, anyway? - and the rest are destined for the dust heap. ...