THT Live

2
0
 THT Live  Links2
Saturday, April 05, 2008 James brouhaha Posted by Dave Studeman There's a baseball brouhaha on the Internet, stoked by Bugs and Cranks' contention that Bill James " thinks steroids fueled the Twins' two championship ." James didn't say that... What he said, in the Bill James Gold Mine , was that Kirby Puckett's and Gary Gaetti's years in 1984 were two of the greatest "underproducers" relative ... [link]

Tags:

Comments

Links (2)

Defending Bill James on Kirby Puckett
Published 4/5/2008 by Eamonn Brennan at The Postmen // A Sports Blog // Chicago, IL.
By now, the Bugs and Cranks post taking Bill James to task on his paragraph in 2008's Gold Mine -- which loosely mentions Kirby Puckett and Gary Gaetti in the same breath as steroids -- is old news. Our boy Josh Alper has given his take too. We get it: It's not cool to bust on Puckett and the Twins for things we do not know. Still, the outrage is not universal. The Hardball Times' Dave Studeman called the Bugs and Cranks headline irresponsible, and Rob Neyer pointed out the irony in a place named Bugs and Cranks taking issue with a slight bit of ...

Defending Bill James on Kirby Puckett
Published 4/5/2008 by Eamonn Brennan at FanHouse
Filed under: Minnesota, Twins, AL Central, MLB Media WatchBy now, the Bugs and Cranks post taking Bill James to task on his paragraph in 2008's Gold Mine -- which loosely mentions Kirby Puckett and Gary Gaetti in the same breath as steroids -- is old news. Our boy Josh Alper has given his take too. We get it: It's not cool to bust on Puckett and the Twins for things we do not know. Still, the outrage is not universal. The Hardball Times' Dave Studeman called the Bugs and Cranks headline irresponsible, and Rob Neyer ...

Related Content

Related Stories
44

Bill James thinks steroids fueled the Twins’ two championships

Two of the greatest home run under-producers of all time were teammates: Kirby Puckett and Gary Gaetti in 1984. Puckett hit no home runs (-16), Gaetti hit only 5 (-19). Suggesting the possibility that the Twins’ two titles may have been aided by their team being among the first to discover…well, I’d better not go there. Nor will I point out that Gaetti was bald and had acne and Puckett died young.
1

THT Live: James brouhaha

There's a baseball brouhaha on the Internet, stoked by Bugs and Cranks' contention that Bill James " thinks steroids fueled the Twins' two championship ." James didn't say that...
1

Bill James's Steroid Accusations Have Higher Range Factor Than Canseco's [J'Accuse]

By now even most casual baseball fans know the story of Bill James. Baseball thought of stats one way, he thought of them another, using complex equations using the quadratic formula and integrals and grep. Easy enough. But perhaps Mr. James has ...
1

Bill James Should Offer Opinions About Win Shares, Not Causes of Death

The worst part of the Steroid Era in baseball is that we'll never be quite sure who was or wasn't on drugs during the years when testing was nonexistent. We all have our suspicions about players whose production and/or muscles exploded but they ...
2

Defending Bill James on Kirby Puckett

By now, the Bugs and Cranks post taking Bill James to task on his paragraph in 2008's Gold Mine -- which loosely mentions Kirby Puckett and Gary Gaetti in the same breath as steroids -- is old news. Our boy Josh Alper has given his take too. We get ...
Related News Articles
Veteren Aces Square-off in Round Two of the Battle of the Underdogs
The Minnesota Twins handed the Kansas City Royals their first loss of the season last night in a tight contest that consisted of good pitching and plenty of small-ball. Both starters had decent performances, neither were spectacular, but Scott ...
Veteran Aces Square Off: Kansas City Royals vs. Minnesota Twins
The Minnesota Twins handed the Kansas City Royals their first loss of the season last night in a tight contest that consisted of good pitching and plenty of small-ball. Both starters had decent performances, neither were spectacular, but Scott ...
Morneau slugs Twins past Royals
A day after obtaining his first hit of the season, Justin Morneau showed further evidence that he's found his stroke, leading the Twins to a 6-4 win over the visiting Royals Saturday afternoon.
Morneau, Twins beat Royals 5-4
Justin Morneau hit his first home run of the season and drove in four runs, and Livan Hernandez won his second straight start for the Minnesota Twins, a 6-4 victory over the Kansas City Royals on Saturday.
Morneau drives in 4, Twins beat Royals (AP)
Justin Morneau hit his first home run of the season and drove in four runs, and Livan Hernandez won his second straight start for the Minnesota Twins, a 6-4 victory over the Kansas City Royals on Saturday. Hernandez (2-0) pitched seven solid ...
Leave a Comment Comment