Submit a Story!
Get the BallHype iPhone App
Yankees may go with Phil Hughes if Andy Pettitte balks
Yankees may go with Phil Hughes if Andy Pettitte balks
Now that the Yankees have landed their new first baseman, the odds of Andy Pettitte being a Yankee next year are "55-45 against," according to a baseball official familiar with the Yanks' plans.
Who Should Be The Fifth Starter?
Who Should Be The Fifth Starter?
slidingintohome.blogspot.com — Pete Caldera from The Record has a new post up on his blog discussing whether the Yankees... should have Phil Hughes or Andy Pettitte as their fifth starter in the upcoming season so I figured I'd do something similar. Hey, why not? In recent days many articles have come out that make it seem that ... (more) Who Should Be The Fifth Starter?
Offer Still Stands, But Yanks Ready To Go With Hughes
Offer Still Stands, But Yanks Ready To Go With Hughes
slidingintohome.blogspot.com — Last night I asked you guys who you thought should be the Yankees fifth starter. So far... Andy Pettitte is out to an early lead in the poll to the left. Here's an update on the Pettitte story. From Anthony McCarron : Before the Yankees signed Mark Teixeira , they told Andy Pettitte 's camp that ... (more) Offer Still Stands, But Yanks Ready To Go With Hughes
Teixeira signing may mean end of Andy Pettitte in pinstripes
weblogs.newsday.com — For the past few weeks, I've been wondering what Andy Pettitte is waiting on in not accepting... the Yankees' one-year, $10 million contract offer. The chances are good now that he has waited too long. As of midday no final... (more) Teixeira signing may mean end of Andy Pettitte in pinstripes
1 Comment
  • TheProgram TheProgram
    +2
    Hughes would be better right now anyway if he can stay healthy.  Why spend more money....really!
    Posted 12/27/2008 respond (flag)
Blog Reactions

Pettitte Still Has Offer From Yanks
MLB Rumors - MLBTradeRumors.com — ... about the Yankees' fading interest in Andy Pettitte, but he still has a $10MM offer from the club for 2009 according to Anthony McCarron of the New York Daily News. ...

55-45 Against
YankeesRedSox.com — Those are the odds against the Yankees signing Andy Pettitte according to a story in today's Daliy News.  I go back and forth on this one.  On one hand, I look at the Yankees rotation and other than Sabathia and Wang who else do you think will pitch 200 innings?  (Sorry, I just don't think you can be positive Burnett will.)  Pettitte provides that at a decent ERA.  But, you also have to look at his second half (13 starts 5.35 ERA) and wonder if he has that ability in him.  And, for $10 million, couldn't you find a cheaper ...

Hughes could get spot if Pettitte, Yanks don't come to terms
Eli's MLB Rumors — ... said on condition of anonymity. "Most (Yankee executives) are thinking of another direction." Still, the door is not closed on Pettitte, and there likely won't be any permanent decision by the Yankees on his future until the new year. A one-year, $10 million offer from the Yanks is still in effect. Several Yankee officials, including Hal Steinbrenner, are on vacation, and the team's offices are scheduled to be closed through New Year's. Source: New York Daily News ...

Andy's Last Chance?
YFSF — ... A number of articles have been written about the dimming chances of an Andy Pettitte return now that the Yanks landed another high-priced free agent. The ubiquitous anonymous sources are doing a fine job of pissing leaking the Yanks' supposed real thinking about the Pettitte negotiations to beat reporters. Anthony McCarron's latest article has one such leaker saying that the chances are 55-45 against the big lefty's return. Interestingly, this same article mentions that the Yanks' 1-year, $10 million offer is still on the table. ...

Pettitte's offer still on table
Scott Proctor's Arm - A New York Yankees Blog — Anthony McCarron spoke to an anonymous Yankee official about the fifth starter spot. According to the official, Andy Pettitte's one-year, $10 million deal is still in effect. But the Yankees aren't so sure he'll return. ...

We still need Andy
Pinstripe Alley — ... The offer of $10 million for Andy Pettitte is still 'on the table', but a Yankee official says there's only about a 50% chance that he takes it. Otherwise, it will be Phil Hughes in the five spot. I'm anxious to see Hughes over the course of a whole season (knock on wood), but we still need Andy for several reasons - ...

Offer Still Stands, But Yanks Ready To Go With Hughes
Sliding Into Home: A Yankees Blog — Last night I asked you guys who you thought should be the Yankees fifth starter. So far Andy Pettitte is out to an early lead in the poll to the left. Here's an update on the Pettitte story. From Anthony McCarron: Before the Yankees signed Mark Teixeira, they told Andy Pettitte's camp that the pitcher's chances of rejoining the Bombers would be in jeopardy if they signed another big free agent. Now that the Yanks have landed their new first baseman, the odds of Pettitte being a Yankee next year are "55-45 against," according ...

Pettitte offer still on the table
River Avenue Blues — ... saga, Anthony McCarron says the Yanks’ one-year, $10-million is still on the table, but Yankee officials don’t seem confident that Pettitte will return to the Bronx. McCarron’s sources put the lefty’s return at 55-45 against, and the team is fully prepared to hand over the final rotation spot to ...

Pettitte still has an offer
N/A — Anthony McCarron reports that a deal is still on the table for pitcher Andy Pettitte from the Yankees: Now that the Yanks have landed their new first baseman, the odds of Pettitte being a Yankee next year are “55-45 against,” according to a baseball official familiar with the Yanks’ plans. “It’s less likely” that Pettitte returns, the official said on condition of anonymity. “Most (Yankee executives) are thinking of another direction.” Still, the door is not closed on Pettitte, and there likely ...

Andy Pettitte’s offer is still on the table. Are the Yankees shifting towards Hughes?
Zell's Pinstripe Blog —      Andy Pettitte still has a $10MM offer from the Yankees for 2009 according to Anthony McCarron of the New York Daily News.   After landing Mark Teixeira,  a baseball official close to the Yankees has said the odds of Pettitte being a Yankee next year are “55-45 against.” The official said that the Yankees may turn to Phil Hughes to fill his spot in the rotation. The Yankees still think highly of Hughes, but they just seem frustrated about the injuries he has had the past two seasons. They haven’t given up on him though. So you may very well see him in the rotation come ...

Life After Pettitte
Beyond the Box Score — ... Obviously, with only two pitches, you have to mix it up.  It is hard to take this guy seriously as a starter - how can he be expected to attempt a third trip around a line-up on a regular basis?  But he looks like a good guy to have on the pen, and handy in an emergency.   Phil Hughes is the obvious guess for the job.  He's not only a well known baseball card collector - he's also a Yankees prospect.  Hughes struck out 38 in 30 innings in the Arizona Fall League in 2008.  He also walked 13 and hit 3 batters, ...

Related Content
Andy Pettitte says no to Yankees
examiner.com 1/6/2009 — After sitting on a $10 million contract offer from the Yankees for two months, Andy Pettitte, according to a report from the New York Times here, has rejected the offer. This is a punch to the gut of all Yankee fans.
Andy Pettitte on the way out?
zellspinstripeblog.com 12/28/2008 — Could this be the end of Pettitte’s run with the Yankees? It very well could be according to many sources. Since adding Mark Teixeira, the Yankees might be shying away from bringing back Pettitte for another year. I think it would be a good idea to bring him back, because you could never have to muc
Andy Pettitte’s offer is still on the table. Are the Yankees shifting towards Hughes?
zellspinstripeblog.com 12/28/2008 — Andy Pettitte still has a $10MM offer from the Yankees for 2009 according to Anthony McCarron of the New York Daily News. After landing Mark Teixeira, a baseball official close to the Yankees has said the odds of Pettitte being a Yankee next year are “55-45 against.” The official said that the Ya
Andy Pettitte Rejects New York Yankees
knucklecurve.com 1/12/2009 — Apparently, the New York Yankees can’t have whatever they want whenever they want. Andy Pettitte recently turned down a contract offer from the Yankees that would have paid him $10 million over one season.
Yankees In Serious Talks With Andy Pettitte
mlbtraderumors.com 1/26/2009 — According to SI.com's Jon Heyman, Andy Pettitte and the Yankees are in serious talks and there's optimism for a deal.
Yankees Notebook: Pettitte’s Return to Yankees Becomes More Unlikely
nytimes.com 1/7/2009 — After Andy Pettitte rejected the Yankees’ one-year, $10 million offer, the negotiations could be viewed in the past tense. >
Pettitte not happy with Yankees right now
newsday.com 1/8/2009 — Andy Pettitte is extremely unhappy with how his negotiations have gone with the Yankees, and the lefthander might be softening on his opposition to rejoining the Astros.
Will Andy Pettitte Return to the Yankees?
nyyankeesrumors.com 1/22/2009 — There has been a lot of debate about whether the Yankees are still interested in trying to bring back Andy Pettitte among with rumors of Ben Sheets and Freddy Garcia floating around. But let’s be clear, Andy is still the Yankees #1 priority. SI.com, citing a baseball source.. Read More
Pettitte not happy with Yankees right now -
newsday.com 1/8/2009 — Andy Pettitte is extremely unhappy with how his negotiations have gone with the Yankees, and the lefthander might be softening on his opposition to rejoining the Astros . What once seemed a fait accompli - Pettitte returning to the Yankees for a 12th ...
Bring Back Andy Pettitte
nyyankeesrumors.com 1/19/2009 — Andy Pettitte left after the final game at Yankee Stadium with every intention of re-negotiating and returning to the team in the spring and try his luck in the new stadium. So what happened? What went wrong exactly? And why isn’t the Yankees management trying harder to bring him back to the pinstri
Embarassing Blunder Leaves Yankees Red-FacedBleacher Report - MLB 12/27/2008
Recently I had an embarrassing misunderstanding with—get this—the New York Yankees. As a lifelong Indians fan, you can imagine my surprise when I discovered a voice mail on my cell phone from Yanks general manager Brian Cashman.  ...
A Sports Fan's New Year's ResolutionsBleacher Report - MLB 12/27/2008
This time each year we decide what we want to fix, do better, or change in the up coming year. I usually pass, as there are just too many possibilities, and, after all, the holidays are depressing enough to some, so why add to it?   This ...
Cheering Section: Whatever Happened to These Fans of 2008?NYT > Baseball 12/27/2008
A look back at the fans featured in this column and their fates. >
Are the Yankees Shifting Towards Hughes?Bleacher Report - MLB 12/28/2008
(Zell's Pinstripe Blog) Andy Pettitte still has a $10 million offer from the Yankees for 2009 according to Anthony McCarron of the New York Daily News.   After landing Mark Teixeira, a baseball official close to the Yankees has said the ...
Andy Pettitte on the Way Out?Bleacher Report - MLB 12/28/2008
(Zell's Pinstripe Blog) Could this be the end of Pettitte’s run with the Yankees? It very well could be according to many sources. Since adding Mark Teixeira, the Yankees might be shying away from bringing back Pettitte for another year.  ...